top of page

Unveiling “The Idol” Controversy: Insight into the conflict behind HBO's newest series

The new HBO Max series “The Idol”, directed by Sam Levinson, has recently gained a lot of media attention and made headlines, with its conflicting storyline and backside production drama. Starring Lily-Rose-Depp and The Weekend, the series revolves around the Los Angles music industry, in which embarks on a romantic relationship following pop star Jocelyn and Tedros, an enigmatic club owner and underground cult leader. The actors stated that they were greatly motivated by their personal experiences in the music industry. This series marks The Weekend’s breakthrough in the acting industry, as he co-created the series with his producing partner Reza Fahim and Sam Levinson, the visionary behind the popular series “Euphoria”. However, the production underwent several challenges and imposed allegations inflicting various altering changes that delayed the production.

“The Idol” was first announced in June 2021 and initiated production soon after. Nearly a year later, Deadline reported on April 25th that groundbreaking changes were being made to the cast, crew, and the "creative vision" of the show. Following HBO's announcement of a six-episode run, the series faced delays, team departures, and a total rework. Director Amy Seimetz departed the project, and Levinson stepped in as director. Followed by Amy’s departure, Rolling Stone released an exposé in March 2023 that included statements from unnamed cast and crew members, outlining a terrible working atmosphere and creative conflicts. The disclosures heightened the project's controversy and uncertainty, resulting in extensive reshoots, rewrites, and production delays. According to Rolling Stone, the series production delays were caused in part by Levinson "scrapping the nearly-finished $54-75 million project to rewrite and reshoot the entire thing."

Not only this, but many people questioned the uncensored and dark topics that the series' subject matter unconventionally covers. Concerning this, The Weekend has come forward to speak about the controversy. When speaking with the New York Times before the show's debut, The Weekend acknowledged The Idol's controversy and dark issues discussed, saying that fans "just need to see the whole show" to comprehend it. He also made a comparison to his profession as a musician. "When I first started making music, it was exactly the same thing," he explained. "I knew it was going to be difficult for people because it was provocative." And that irritated a lot of people. Not to draw parallels, but I have the impression that this is similar. This will not appeal to everyone, which is great. We are not politicians.

Lily-Rose Depp also came forward defending the show and displayed her admiration towards Sam Levison, denying the rumors of a toxic working environment. "Sam is, for so many reasons, the best director I have ever worked with," the actress stated in March 2023 in a statement to PEOPLE. "Never before have I felt more supported or respected in a creative space, my input, and opinions more valued," she concluded. "Working with Sam is a true collaboration in every way — he cares more than anything about what his actors think about the work, but also how we feel performing it.”. "He hires people whose work he values and has always created an environment in which I felt seen, heard, and appreciated," she said.

Overall "The Idol" is a bold and unconventional project that may not appeal to everyone but has piqued the interest of viewers. As the series premieres, viewers will be able to create their own judgments and evaluate if it lives up to the media interest it has received.


bottom of page